- In almost all the cases, the girl is an innocent victim. In very few cases it so happens that the girl blindly trusts some stranger or so and gets trapped in such things.
- Assuming the first case above, if it's not her fault, why does she have to suffer? We are used to the situation when the accused can live freely even after such deeds, if so, then the question is still more logical - why does then only she have to suffer?
- If the accused has all that backup from whoever they are, why cannot the girl get the same, or more support from her family and friends?
- Why can such an incident not be considered as a mishap or accident, can be taken actions on and then move on?
- Why can no one accept the victim?
What will be our reaction if we heard/read about following cases?
- A businessman getting betrayed by his partner and losing all the money he had
- A graduated, jobless person getting betrayed by a fake agency which promises him to give job but vanishes taking all his money
- A lady getting robbed by a fake salesman who takes away all her jewellery
- A fake institution collecting money from people and then not giving returns
- A girl getting molested by her boyfriend(?)
- A man who travels late night in the train and gets beaten up and robbed
- A woman who works late night getting attacked when she is returning home
When a girl trusts her boyfriend or a colleague, that's her crime and when a businessman trusts his partner, it's just a small mistake?! When a women gets molested, it's her fault that she is working late night; but if a man gets robbed or beaten, 'what can be done now? It's destiny! Just be careful next time!' - why not these simple, caring words for a woman? Why does she have to hear - 'who told u to work till this time? you could have picked up another job. whatever happens in the future, you yourself will be responsible for that.' Why this difference? Because, all that a woman is judged on is her virginity - no matter how she is by nature, how intelligent / hard working / kind / caring / responsible / irresponsible / genuine she is. It all comes to her virginity. She is not accepted once she goes through anything which is against the norms of society.
And as I suppose, it's this negligence or rejection is what is most scary, even more than the actual incident. To her (ex-)boyfriend, it mostly does not matter how much she loved him in past, once she gets molested by someone. Her friends will mostly forget the moments they enjoyed with her, they will mostly forget that she exists. Her relatives will mostly cut down all interactions with her family. It happens, currently it does. They don't accept her because she has been through something which is against the norms set by society. But, there are few others too who are responsible for this. If we cannot reject them, who gives us right to reject her?
I just hope and pray that if we cannot prevent such incidents from happening, we will at least learn to accept the victims. They could be our sisters, wives, daughters, nieces.. anyone..! All we should do is not to prevent our daughters and wives from choosing some specific career or job or way of living but give them support, backup and a caring word that no matter what happens, they will remain part of the family. At least till the time, when the woman is considered just a woman and not a human being.
9 टिप्पणी(ण्या):
A well written post ! .. it surely highlights the root cause of what makes crimes against women a life shattering experience only for them.
But you know what , the answer lies within ourselves. I remember your post written some days back..Be the change you want to see in the world.
So lets vow to be a become a woman who would readily accept another such woman who has been a victim of a crime like this. Lets vow to become a mother who will not persuade her daughter to marry just for a sense of social security, lets not accept the virginity norm if put forward by any guy. Hell with that guy, dont marry him. If everyone follows the suit, he would be left with no woman to marry at all.
But women are known to be their own enemies by having weak minds. They hardly have the courage to flow against the current, to face the hardships that, that path might offer them. Half of them just want to tug along their husbands / boyfriends, and are happy if their opinions are not taken seriously. The "Adarsh bhartiya nari syndrome" :D
In fact there are girls who educate themselves just to make their resume look good for a marriage application .. :P
If you happen to visit any famous marriage bureaus even in pune you will come to know about this mentality.
If we can raise women above all this to make them independent, bold and confident, it will bring about lot of change in women's position in the society.
However we cannot still say that crimes against them will be stopped. We can just see to it that laws are enforced strictly and judicary helps women.
These would be better steps than getting 33 % reservation anywhere.
"Treat a woman as a fellow human being "
@ Hermione,
On first reading of your reply, I was so excited that I agreed to most of the things. But, now while reading it again, I think the following. I totally agree with your opinion about we changing ourselves in order to see that change in the world. But at the same time I believe that "adarsh naaree" is not to be made fun of. I feel that it's perfectly fine to be "adarsh naaree" / "adarsh wife" in terms of carrying out her responsibilities; but not by exchange of her freedom and basic rights. As long as she is being treated as a human being and not just a woman, it's totally fine. Unfortunately most of the times, it's not the case and that's what made you write this, I guess.
Also as you mentioned about getting educated to add stuff in their resume for marriage - sometimes that does create an obstacle instead of helping. And I feel that in such cases, she should not feel bad of she being highly educated. In fact she should make most of it - in terms of being able to be independent and confident. One more point reg. this and the recent incident happened in Hinjawadi, Pune. Most of the people argued that the girl who was attacked was highly educated / was in America for some time; still how could she trust some strangers? I remember the incident that happened sometime in 2006, in the nearby area - Wakad where someone took lift from strangers and was found dead later. Of course then too was his mistake of trusting some strangers. How is that different and why do they stress in this case that the girl was highly educated / did she assume that this is America? and of course, she should not have trusted them but more than stressing this point that she trusted them, isn't that important to acknowledge that the area is not safe. There can be people around you with traps which you might fall in. I mean, what?! So all I want to say is - when a girl is highly educated, it is rarely taken neutrally. Either it creates obstacles in finding a groom for her or it kind-of makes fun of her - as if "higher education" means you are not allowed to make any mistakes!
And frankly, I too get such experience quite frequently - of people making fun of me seeing I have ambitions to pursue and dreams to follow - and they keep pointing every small mistake that I do - saying this is not expected from you.
@Megha
I have no intentions of making fun of bhartiya naree, as it is indian-ness which has honed her in to becoming a good human being. It is the indian thought process which has taught her (or him) "tyagat shanti nirantanam". The western culture is too naive to arrive at this process of discovering happiness by giving up your desires or sometimes even freedom as you might call it.
And as for education my only point was to say that aim of pursuing education should be to become enlighetened, knowledgeable and wise; but not to increase your "value" in marriage market.
Whether education actually causes increase / decrease in your value is a different story altogether.
My objection is only at the point of view towards education some women have. It is a total paradox to the purpose of acquiring knowledge.
Right you are! :)
hey amazing post...i specially liked the point you made about the businessman being cheated by a partner and its similarity with the topic..nice post..keep writing
Thanks Aruna. I wanted to bring out precisely the same point.
Indeed very well written.. !! I too liked the comparison. That's more than enough to make the point.
Another thing, it's not just the men or the society. It's our very own law which demands the woman/victim to prove herself not guilty in the rape case. Shouldn't it be exactly opposite?
Anyways.. Keep writing.. all the best..
Thanks Heramb. Yes, I agree with you.
"why would one be scared of the most and the only unavoidable thing in human life?" - Fear of death has probably been the oldest of all fears; as old as our existence itself. The reason for any kind of fear can be generalized as fear of the unknown. Whenever fear exists, it can be traced to some missing knowledge.
Fear of death is just an example of the same where we have no knowledge of after-death.
Post a Comment